+90 312 219 54 51[email protected]Koç Towers, Söğütözü · Ankara
Banko Law Firm & Mediation Speak to a lawyer
Article · Dispute Resolution & Mediation

Failure to List Each Claim in the Mediation Report Cannot Justify Dismissal: The Constitutional Court's Access-to-Court Judgment

Banko Law Firm & Mediation2 min read

In its judgment of 18 May 2026 in application No. 2023/33449, the Constitutional Court held that an excessively formalistic approach to the form of the final report in mandatory pre-trial mediation violated the right of access to a court. The judgment was published in the Official Gazette No. 33406 of 20 October 2026.

In the case, the applicant brought an action for severance pay and overtime pay after his employment contract ended due to military service. The first-instance court accepted the claim; however, on the employer's appeal, the regional court of appeal dismissed the action on procedural grounds for lack of a condition of action, because the individual claims had not been listed one by one in the final mediation report.

The Constitutional Court found that the phrase “arising from the employee–employer relationship” in the report did not change the fact that the claims had been discussed during the mediation. It considered it excessively burdensome to place the entire responsibility for the general wording not being specified on the applicant, and found that the approach of the regional court of appeal imposed an extraordinary burden on him. The Court unanimously held that the right of access to a court under Article 36 of the Constitution had been violated and ordered the file to be sent to the relevant court for retrial.

Article 3 of the Labour Courts Law No. 7036 makes applying to a mediator a condition of action in cases concerning employee or employer claims and compensation based on law or on individual or collective employment contracts, and in reinstatement claims. The purpose of this condition is to allow the dispute first to be resolved amicably; where that purpose has been achieved, formal shortcomings in the report should not lead to a loss of rights.

In conclusion, the judgment shows that a proportionate approach must be adopted in interpreting mediation reports. Nonetheless, to avoid disputes in practice, it remains important to state the claims in dispute clearly in the mediation application and in the final report.

Sources · Kaynaklar

  • Anayasa Mahkemesi, B. No: 2023/33449, 18.05.2026 (RG 20.10.2026/33406)
  • 7036 sayılı İş Mahkemeleri Kanunu m.3
  • Anayasa m.36
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. The English text is a translation; in case of discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.