+90 312 219 54 51[email protected]Koç Towers, Söğütözü · Ankara
Banko Law Firm & Mediation Speak to a lawyer
Article · Constitutional Law & Individual Applications

Constitutional Court Pilot Judgment on Freedom of Expression in Penal Institutions

Banko Law Firm & Mediation3 min read

By its judgment of 19 February 2026 in application No. 2019/789, published in the Official Gazette No. 33392 of 6 October 2026, the Plenary of the Constitutional Court found that freedom of expression had been violated through the withholding of documents belonging to persons held in penal institutions and the blocking of access to periodical and non-periodical publications sent from outside. The Court also found that the structural problems relating to these practices persisted beyond individual applications and could lead to many similar violations. It therefore decided to apply the pilot judgment procedure so that the problem would be remedied not only for the applicants but also for others in a similar situation.

In the events giving rise to the applications, books, newspapers, magazines and various written documents belonging to convicts and detainees in various penal institutions, or sent to them by post and courier, were examined by the institution administrations. It was decided that some publications would not be handed over and would be retained by various methods on the grounds that they contained terrorist propaganda, were obscene, endangered institutional security or were otherwise objectionable. Individual applications were lodged after challenges to these decisions before the enforcement judges and assize courts were unsuccessful.

The Constitutional Court first examined whether there was a legal basis for penal institutions to withhold documents belonging to prisoners. It found that Articles 35 and 62 of Law No. 5275 and the secondary legislation issued on their basis did not regulate the seizure of prisoners' documents or their retention by other means. It therefore concluded that the interferences did not satisfy the requirement of lawfulness.

The judgment also addressed current practice regarding access to periodical and non-periodical publications sent to penal institutions from outside. The Court stated that whether publications are admitted to the institution must be assessed in line with Law No. 5275 and the criteria set out in the Court's settled case-law. However, it found that despite various earlier violation judgments and findings of structural problems, no uniform, foreseeable and effective review mechanism had been established in practice for handing publications over to prisoners.

The Court noted in particular that the provision of Article 62 of Law No. 5275, under which certain publications are not to be given to prisoners, was not sufficiently clear as to the procedure by which such publications are subsequently kept or withheld by the institution administration. The use in practice of different concepts for the same type of measure, and the lack of clearly defined legal consequences for those measures, were also assessed in terms of the principles of lawfulness and legal certainty.

In conclusion, the Constitutional Court found that the applicants' freedom of expression had been violated and decided to apply the pilot judgment procedure to remedy the existing structural problems concerning access to documents and publications in penal institutions. The judgment confirms once again that it is not sufficient for interferences with freedom of expression in penal institutions merely to pursue a legitimate aim; the interference must have a legal basis, be sufficiently clear and foreseeable, and be applied in line with the safeguards established in the Constitutional Court's case-law.

Sources · Kaynaklar

  • AYM Genel Kurulu, B. No: 2019/789, 19.02.2026 (RG 06.10.2026/33392)
  • 5275 sayılı Kanun m.35, m.62
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. The English text is a translation; in case of discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.