+90 312 219 54 51[email protected]Koç Towers, Söğütözü · Ankara
Banko Law Firm & Mediation Speak to a lawyer
Article · Family, Inheritance & Real Estate

The Evidential Value of Audio Recordings in Divorce Proceedings

Banko Law Firm & Mediation3 min read

Because insults, threats, violence, breaches of the duty of fidelity and conduct undermining trust in divorce cases often take place within the spouses' private sphere, audio recordings are frequently relied on to prove these facts. However, the fact that a recording reveals an alleged fact does not mean that it can be relied on in the judgment on its own. How and under what conditions the evidence was obtained matters as much as its content.

Audio recordings taken without the knowledge and consent of the other spouse, in breach of the privacy of private life or communications, are regarded as unlawfully obtained evidence. In particular, it is accepted that recordings obtained by eavesdropping on the environment, by placing a hidden recording device or camera in the shared home, or by secretly recording the spouse's conversations with third parties cannot be relied on in the judgment. The 2nd Civil Chamber of the Court of Cassation has also characterised images and audio obtained by placing a hidden camera in the shared home as unlawful evidence. Living in the same home does not give one spouse unlimited authority to monitor and record the other spouse's private life.

Creating the recording through a third party does not change the outcome. Where one spouse enlists a third party to get the other spouse to talk about a particular matter and the conversation is secretly recorded, the method of obtaining the recording is separately examined for lawfulness. In addition, the inability to establish the source, method of creation or integrity of the recording is important for the reliability of the evidence.

The fact that an unlawful recording cannot be relied on does not prevent the fact contained in it from being proved by other evidence. However, that evidence must be independent of the recording. It is not considered possible to use the statement of a witness whose knowledge derives solely from listening to the unlawful recording in order to bring the content of the recording indirectly into the proceedings. Secret recording may have consequences not only for the admissibility of evidence but also for determining the fault of the recording spouse in the divorce. The aim of exposing the other spouse's misconduct does not, by itself, make an unlawful intrusion into private life lawful. From a criminal law perspective, the use of a recording as evidence in divorce proceedings and criminal liability arising from the recording must be assessed separately. The purpose for which the recording was made, the nature of its content and whether it was shared with third parties are important. In particular, playing or sharing private conversations with persons outside the case, or placing a listening device in the home of a separated spouse, may, depending on the circumstances, also constitute offences such as violation of the privacy of private life or unlawful obtaining or dissemination of personal data. The criminal law consequences of making and using the recording should therefore be considered separately.

Nevertheless, recordings made by a person who has no other means of obtaining evidence in a sudden incident directed against them should not be treated in the same way as pre-planned secret recordings. Accordingly, there can be no general acceptance that secret audio recordings may be made to obtain evidence in divorce cases without regard to the specific circumstances.

In conclusion, in determining the evidential value of audio recordings, the method of obtaining them, the nature of the intrusion into private life, the reliability of the recording and the other available evidence must be considered together with the content. In each case, it is important to strike a balance between the right to obtain evidence and the protection of the privacy of private life and communications.

Sources · Kaynaklar

  • 6100 sayılı HMK m.189/2
  • Anayasa m.20, 22, 38/6
  • 5237 sayılı TCK m.133, 134, 136
  • Yargıtay 2. HD, E.2023/7996, K.2024/5004, T.27.06.2024 (ortak konuta gizli kamera)
  • Yargıtay 2. HD, E.2025/5186, K.2025/7559 (ortam dinlemesi niteliğindeki ses kaydı)
This article is for general information only and does not constitute legal advice. The English text is a translation; in case of discrepancy, the Turkish text prevails.